Nordic Margins
A silver rigid airship over a dark ocean at night between a lit city skyline on one coast and a harbour on the other

NYLAST: Nordling's plan for a New York to London passenger airship

Late in life Nordling sketched a transatlantic airship service that would compete with jet travel on comfort, not speed. The numbers are worth following, and so are the problems he left open.

Maritime cases 6 min read

The great passenger airships had a short career. The German Graf Zeppelin began regular transatlantic service to South America in the early 1930s, and the larger Hindenburg flew between Frankfurt and Lakehurst, New Jersey, in 1936. When the Hindenburg burned while landing at Lakehurst on 6 May 1937, killing 36 people, the era of hydrogen airships effectively ended. Fixed-wing aircraft took over the North Atlantic after the Second World War, and the jet age reduced the crossing to a matter of hours.

Carl O. Nordling, an architect who had spent his career planning towns and housing, revisited the idea in the 2000s under the name NYLAST, for New York–London Air-Ship Traffic. He called it "a fancy project" and published it as a rough sketch, inviting specialists in each field to criticize and improve it. It is a good example of how he liked to think: begin with a human need, translate it into a timetable, and let the timetable decide the engineering.

A timetable built around sleep

Nordling's starting point was comfort. A passenger who wants to cross the Atlantic without a week at sea has to accept an airliner seat. He imagined a third option that cost only one working day: board in the evening, dine, sleep six to eight hours, spend a day with restaurants, lounges and somewhere to work, sleep again, and land after breakfast.

Leaving at 6 p.m. on the first day and arriving around 9 a.m. on the third, with a five-hour time difference between London and New York, gives about 34 hours flying eastward and 44 hours westward. Those two figures fixed the rest of the design.

Winds, routes and speed

The great-circle distance between the two cities is roughly 5,600 kilometers. Westerly winds prevail over the North Atlantic, so the eastward flight would usually have a tailwind. Nordling calculated that an airship with a cruising airspeed of 150 kilometers per hour would need only a following wind of a little over four meters per second to make London in 34 hours.

The westward trip was harder. Flying straight into the wind would only work in light headwinds. Instead he proposed a northern route chosen for each flight according to the weather: from London past the Hebrides, along the coasts of Iceland and Greenland to the Labrador Sea, then over Labrador, the St. Lawrence and Vermont to New York. Though longer, about 6,300 kilometers, that track would often have favorable or crossing winds, and 150 kilometers per hour would still bring the ship in within 44 hours. He wanted engines that could push to about 170 kilometers per hour in reserve.

A ship the size of a small town

Capacity and dimensions

Economy, in his view, required large numbers: about 500 paying passengers and 50 tonnes of cargo per trip, with up to 700 people if every cabin was filled. Each passenger would have a cabin. His preliminary dimensions were a length of about 370 meters and a diameter of about 67 meters, with a gas volume of around 870,000 cubic meters. For comparison, the Hindenburg was about 245 meters long with roughly 200,000 cubic meters of gas, so NYLAST would have been more than four times its volume.

Gas, fuel and engines

He assumed helium as the lifting gas, since hydrogen's flammability had been demonstrated beyond argument. For fuel he considered a combination: oil for most of the journey, then hydrogen burned in the final stage. As the oil was consumed the ship would grow lighter and climb to around 2,000 meters, where the thinner air reduces drag, and burning hydrogen at the end would let it descend without venting expensive helium or dropping ballast. That depended on engines able to run efficiently on both fuels, and he mentioned lightweight Stirling engines as a possibility he had read about but could not verify. Historically, the Graf Zeppelin had burned a gaseous fuel of about the same density as air for a similar reason, while the Hindenburg used diesel engines.

Structure and layout

For the hull he suggested a geodesic framework adapted from Buckminster Fuller's domes, stretched into a streamlined shape, using modern aluminum alloys, carbon fiber and synthetic fabrics in place of the duralumin and cotton of the 1930s. Propulsion might use ducted fans running through the hull with steerable thrusters at bow and stern instead of external propeller gondolas and tail fins. Cabins would line two decks along the sides, each with a window angled downward, while restaurants, cinemas, lounges and reading rooms would occupy full decks below.

The problems he left open

Nordling was frank that several questions were beyond him. He had no answer for icing on the envelope, a serious hazard on a route past Greenland. He asked readers to suggest mooring methods. For terminals he looked for open land close to each city center in the direction of travel: the disused Flushing Airport in Queens for New York, and in London open spaces such as Wormwood Scrubs or Parliament Hill, which would hardly be made available for the purpose.

There are larger obstacles he did not address. A ship that size would need enormous hangars and large ground crews, and handling it near the ground in gusty weather is notoriously difficult; several of the great rigid airships of the 1920s and 1930s were lost in storms or on landing. Helium supply is limited and expensive. Weather routing is easier with satellites than it was in the 1930s, but a slow ship cannot outrun a winter storm system the size of the North Atlantic. The jet airliner also keeps getting cheaper.

None of this makes the sketch worthless. Interest in large airships has returned several times since the 1990s, mostly for cargo and for regions without roads, and several firms have built prototypes. Passenger service of the kind Nordling imagined has not followed. His proposal is best read as an exercise in design thinking from an engineer of the old school who believed that comfort, time and physics could be balanced by calculation.

The same habit of working through numbers drove his reconstruction of the Andrea Doria and Stockholm collision, and his career as a planner is described on the page about Carl O. Nordling.

Questions and answers

What does NYLAST stand for?

NYLAST stands for New York–London Air-Ship Traffic, the name Carl O. Nordling gave to his sketch of a transatlantic passenger airship service. He presented it as an open proposal, inviting experts in aerodynamics, engines, materials and airport planning to criticize the figures and suggest improvements.

How long would the crossing have taken?

Nordling planned about 34 hours eastbound, helped by prevailing westerly winds, and about 44 hours westbound on a weather-dependent northern route past Iceland and Greenland. Passengers would leave in the evening and arrive after breakfast two days later, losing only one working day while sleeping two nights on board.

How big would the airship have been?

His estimate was about 370 meters long and 67 meters in diameter, holding roughly 870,000 cubic meters of gas. That is far larger than the Hindenburg, which measured about 245 meters. It was meant to carry around 500 passengers in individual cabins plus about 50 tonnes of cargo.

Why did passenger airships disappear?

Fixed-wing aircraft became faster, cheaper and more reliable, while rigid airships proved costly and hard to handle in bad weather. A series of accidents, ending with the burning of the hydrogen-filled Hindenburg at Lakehurst in May 1937, destroyed public confidence. After the Second World War, passenger airships were not revived on long-distance routes.

Continue the voyage

Two ocean liners passing close in fog and a heavy sea at night, with a lit airship crossing the sky above them
Maritime cases

Andrea Doria and Stockholm, 1956

Read
Cut-paper night scene of a Swedish-speaking coastal village in Finland: red wooden houses, a white church and birches above a moonlit harbour with rowing boats
The Finland-Swedes

Swedish-speaking Finns: an introduction

Read
Searchlights crossing over a snowy forest at night while a line of soldiers on skis crosses a frozen lake towards a lit village
Stalin and the Second World War

World War II

Read