Nordic Margins
A moonlit South Pacific beach with tall palms, a thatched Samoan fale glowing from inside and an outrigger canoe on the sand

Margaret Mead and Samoa: Coming of Age and the Freeman debate

Few books in anthropology have been as admired or as fiercely attacked. Carl O. Nordling sided with Mead's critic Derek Freeman, but the later scholarship gives a more mixed verdict.

Science and society 5 min read

In 1925 Margaret Mead, a 23-year-old graduate student of Franz Boas at Columbia University, sailed to American Samoa to study adolescent girls. She spent about nine months there, most of it on the island of Ta'ū in the Manu'a group, and in 1928 published the result as Coming of Age in Samoa, with a foreword by Boas. The book argued that Samoan girls passed through adolescence without the emotional storms familiar in America, and it attributed the difference to culture: a relaxed attitude to sex, few conflicting ideals and little pressure to choose among them.

It became one of the best-selling works of anthropology ever written. For decades it served as a classic example of the power of culture over biology and was widely read in universities. Mead herself became the most famous anthropologist in the United States.

Freeman's 1983 attack

In 1983, five years after Mead's death, the New Zealand anthropologist Derek Freeman published Margaret Mead and Samoa: The Making and Unmaking of an Anthropological Myth. Freeman had worked in Samoa from the 1940s onward and spoke the language fluently. He argued that Mead had got Samoa badly wrong.

According to Freeman, Samoan society placed great value on female virginity before marriage, especially for girls of high rank. A bride's virginity could be tested publicly, and the loss of it brought shame and punishment. Samoans were competitive, quick to anger, and had high rates of violence and of adolescent delinquency. Mead's picture of easy adolescent sexuality and low stress, he said, reflected her own expectations and Boas's theoretical program, not what she had observed.

In a later book, The Fateful Hoaxing of Margaret Mead (1999), Freeman went further. He drew on a 1987 filmed interview with Fa'apua'a Fa'amū, one of two young Samoan women who had traveled with Mead in 1926. Fa'apua'a said that she and her friend had invented tales of nightly liaisons as a joke, a common Samoan pastime, and that Mead had taken them seriously. Freeman argued that this hoax was the main source of Mead's conclusions about sexual freedom.

Nordling's reading

Carl O. Nordling followed Freeman closely. In his essay "Margaret Mead, the Sociological Illusionist", he described Mead as having arrived with a fixed expectation, abandoned her planned interviews when they produced little, and accepted her friends' stories because they fitted. He noted that her own table of 25 girls showed thirteen with no sexual experience at all and listed no pregnancies among the others, which he found hard to square with her conclusions. He also criticized the book's thin documentation, which rarely distinguished between Mead's observations and information from earlier literature.

Nordling's criticism extended to Boas, whom he accused of endorsing the work for ideological reasons, and to Mead's later book Sex and Temperament in Three Primitive Societies (1935), on the Arapesh, Mundugumor and Tchambuli of New Guinea. He argued that the contrasts in temperament Mead described reflected heredity and natural selection more than culture. That hereditarian reading of human group differences is not shared by modern anthropology, and it goes well beyond Freeman's own argument, which concerned the accuracy of Mead's ethnography.

The replies to Freeman

Freeman's book caused an uproar. At the American Anthropological Association meeting in 1983 a motion was passed criticizing it, and many reviewers accused him of overstatement and of attacking a dead scholar who could not respond. Over the following decades the debate settled into a more careful assessment, and several points emerged.

First, both observers had worked in different places and decades. Mead was in remote Manu'a in the 1920s, a time of mission influence and recent colonial change. Freeman's main fieldwork was in Western Samoa from the 1940s onward. Samoan practice was not uniform, and the ideal of virginity for high-ranking girls did not mean it governed the behavior of every adolescent.

Second, close readings of Mead's field notes and letters, especially by Martin Orans in Not Even Wrong (1996) and Paul Shankman in The Trashing of Margaret Mead (2009), found that she had collected more data than Freeman allowed and that her account of adolescent sexuality did not depend on the conversation with Fa'apua'a. Shankman argued that Mead had already formed her views before that trip and that the hoaxing claim was overstated. Orans, for his part, concluded that Mead's conclusions were too vague to be tested properly at all.

Third, Freeman's own account was criticized for presenting Samoan society as more uniformly strict and violent than the evidence supported, and for relying heavily on court and police records.

A further point concerns what Mead was asked to do. Boas had framed the project as a test case: if adolescent turmoil was absent in even one society, it could not be a universal product of biology. That design meant a single counterexample carried great theoretical weight, which helps explain both the book's influence and the intensity of the later attack. Critics of Mead have argued that the conclusion was built into the question; her defenders reply that the question was legitimate and that her answer, whatever its flaws, was an empirical claim open to checking, which is exactly what happened.

Where the debate stands

Most anthropologists today agree that Coming of Age in Samoa overstated the ease of Samoan adolescence and that Mead's methods were weak by later standards. Few accept Freeman's portrait of her as simply duped, or his own image of Samoa as the complete picture. The episode is now taught as a lesson about the influence of expectation on fieldwork, the limits of a single observer, and the way a scholarly dispute can become a public quarrel about nature and nurture.

Nordling's essay belongs to the critical side of that argument and shares Freeman's view of the Samoan evidence. His wider conclusions about heredity are his own and fall outside the academic consensus. Like his essays on the Big Bang and the Kensington runestone, it shows his habit of taking on established authorities. For his best-founded challenge to received wisdom, see the history of the multi-mutation theory of cancer.

Questions and answers

What did Margaret Mead claim in Coming of Age in Samoa?

Mead argued that adolescence in Samoa was a relatively calm period, without the stress and rebellion common in the United States, and that this was due to culture. She described a relaxed attitude toward premarital sex and few conflicting ideals. The book became a landmark for the view that culture shapes human behavior more than biology.

What did Derek Freeman argue?

In his 1983 book Freeman, who had long experience in Samoa, said Mead's portrait was badly wrong: Samoans valued virginity, punished its loss, and had substantial violence and adolescent conflict. In 1999 he added the claim that two young women had hoaxed Mead with invented stories, which he believed had shaped her conclusions.

Was Margaret Mead hoaxed?

Fa'apua'a Fa'amū stated in 1987 that she and a friend had joked with Mead about sexual adventures. Researchers who later examined Mead's field notes, notably Paul Shankman, argued that her conclusions came from wider material collected before that conversation. Most scholars now see the hoaxing claim as an exaggeration, while agreeing that Mead's work had real methodological weaknesses.

What is Nordling's view of the controversy?

Nordling sided strongly with Freeman, criticizing Mead's evidence, her documentation and Boas's endorsement of the book. He also argued that differences in temperament between peoples she studied in New Guinea reflected heredity, a reading that modern anthropology rejects and that Freeman's own critique did not make.

Continue the voyage

A lit study window with a microscope, a lamp and books, looking out over a snowy city by the water under a spiral galaxy
Science and society

The multi-mutation theory, 1953

Read
A 1930s city at night seen from a rooftop: still factory chimneys, idle harbour cranes and new apartment blocks under construction
Science and society

Origin of a Depression

Read
An empty Stockholm street corner on a winter night: old stone facades, a dark cinema canopy, steps down to the subway and a single street lamp in the snow
Science and society

The murder of Olof Palme

Read