Nordic Margins
A small Viking-age trading town on a lake island at night: turf-roofed longhouses, boats at a wooden jetty and a tiny chapel on the hill

Ansgar's mission to the Swedes: was Birka on Björkö or on Åland?

The first Christian mission to the Swedes landed at a place the chroniclers called Birca. Nordling questioned whether it was the island in Lake Mälaren that bears the name today.

Scandinavian history 6 min read

Around the year 830 a Frankish monk named Ansgar set out for the land of the Swedes at the invitation, so the story goes, of a Swedish delegation at the court of Louis the Pious. His party was robbed by pirates on the way, lost most of what it carried, and continued partly overland until it reached a trading town called Birca. There a local ruler named Björn received them, a royal official called Herigar was converted and built a church on his own land, and a small Christian congregation took root. Ansgar went on to become archbishop of Hamburg-Bremen and was later venerated as the apostle of the North.

The account comes from the Vita Anskarii, written around 870 by Rimbert, Ansgar's companion and successor. Some two centuries later Adam of Bremen, in his history of the archbishops of Hamburg completed around 1075, described Birca again and listed later missionaries sent there, among them Unni, who died there in 936.

The accepted location: Björkö in Lake Mälaren

Since the seventeenth century Birca has been identified with the island of Björkö in Lake Mälaren, west of present-day Stockholm. Excavations from the 1680s onward, and on a large scale since the nineteenth century, have uncovered a town of the eighth to tenth centuries with thousands of graves, a harbor, a hillfort and imported goods from as far away as the Islamic world. Together with the royal estate at Hovgården on the neighboring island of Adelsö, Birka was inscribed as a UNESCO World Heritage Site in 1993. For archaeologists and historians the identification is secure: no other site in Sweden matches its size and date.

Nordling's objections

Carl O. Nordling found the story hard to square with what happened afterward. If a mission had worked from 830 onward in the heart of the Mälaren valley, close to the pagan cult center at Uppsala, why did no Swedish king accept baptism until Olof Skötkonung around 1008, and why did he do so at Husaby in Västergötland, hundreds of kilometers away? Why did Christian burial customs appear in the Mälaren region only in the eleventh century? And why would a succession of pagan kings tolerate a foreign church in the middle of their main market town?

He also pointed out that birk or birka appears to have been a common noun for a trading place with its own law, not a unique proper name. Places called Birka or Byrcke existed in several parts of Sweden into the sixteenth century, and Finland has Pirkkala near Tampere. If the word meant "the market", a chronicler might easily have merged reports of two different markets into one.

Reading the Latin closely

Nordling's method was to take the medieval texts literally until a statement plainly could not mean what it said. He noticed that Rimbert has Ansgar's party cross "the intervening seas" (interiacentia maria) after leaving their ships, using the word for open salt water, and that the town is called a vicus, a settlement or trading village, with a larger civitas nearby to which the inhabitants fled when Danes attacked. Neither author, he observed, calls Birca an island.

Adam of Bremen supplied more clues. He describes Birca as lying on an inlet of the Baltic that runs northward, as the safest anchorage in the maritime region of the Swedes, approached through dangerous shallows, and as standing at equal distance from all the coasts of the surrounding sea. In another passage he says that the missionary Hiltin, also called Johannes, was sent "to the islands of the Baltic Sea".

The case for Saltvik on Åland

Nordling proposed that these descriptions fit a site on Åland better than Björkö. At Saltvik, on the main island, a long inlet runs north from the open sea, the approaches pass through shallow narrows, and about two kilometers away rises Borge, a rocky hill with the remains of an ancient fortification that a visitor might have called an urbs or civitas. Åland lies roughly midway between the Swedish and Finnish coasts. The parish has an unusually large number of Iron Age graves.

He listed eleven points on which Saltvik matched the sources and two on which it did not: no document calls Saltvik a birk, and it is not near Uppsala, as Adam explicitly says Birca was. He did not claim to have proved the location. His conclusion was that Björkö had been assumed, not demonstrated, and that the question deserved to be reopened.

Åland already had its own champion of a similar idea. The Åland historian Matts Dreijer argued in the 1980s that Birka lay at Saltvik, and his work is the best-known version of the theory. Nordling's study arrived at the same place by a philological route.

How historians respond

Specialists have not been persuaded, for several reasons. Rimbert's and Adam's geography is notoriously loose; Adam never visited Sweden and assembled his descriptions from informants, so a literal reading can prove too much. The archaeological record at Björkö matches the period of Ansgar's visits and includes finds that point to a Christian presence, such as cross pendants, in some graves. Saltvik has rich Iron Age remains, yet nothing on the scale of a major international market of the ninth century has been excavated there. Most historians also read the slow conversion of the Swedes as normal for the period: a missionary foothold in a trading town did not require the king to convert, and missions in Scandinavia often lapsed for decades.

The Åland theory therefore remains a minority position. It does point at a real difficulty, which is that the written sources are vague and that the identification rests mainly on archaeology. Anyone who reads the Vita Anskarii with Björkö in mind will notice how little of the text is specific to that island.

Questions about how Swedish and Finnish settlement overlapped in the same region come up again in the essay on Finland's province names. The broader collection is introduced on the Scandinavian history page, and the role of Åland and the coastal Swedes in later centuries is followed in the Finland-Swedes series.

Questions and answers

Who was Ansgar?

Ansgar (801–865) was a Benedictine monk from the abbey of Corbie who became the first archbishop of Hamburg and later of the united see of Hamburg-Bremen. He led missions to Denmark and twice to the Swedes, around 830 and again around 852. His life was written by his successor Rimbert, and he is remembered as the apostle of the North.

Where is Birka according to archaeologists?

Archaeologists place Birka on the island of Björkö in Lake Mälaren, about thirty kilometers west of Stockholm. Excavations there have revealed a town of the eighth to tenth centuries, a hillfort, a harbor and several thousand graves. Birka and the nearby royal site of Hovgården on Adelsö are listed together as a UNESCO World Heritage Site.

What evidence did Nordling use for Åland?

He relied on close reading of the Latin texts by Rimbert and Adam of Bremen: references to crossing seas, to a northward inlet of the Baltic, to treacherous shallows, to a nearby fortified "city", and to a missionary sent to the Baltic islands. He argued that Saltvik and the hillfort of Borge on Åland matched these details better than Björkö did.

Is the Åland theory accepted today?

No. Historians and archaeologists continue to identify Birka with Björkö, because its finds fit the period and scale described in the sources and because the medieval descriptions are too imprecise to support a literal reading. The Saltvik theory, associated above all with Matts Dreijer, is treated as an interesting but unproven alternative.

Continue the voyage

A grey stone island fortress with bastions and ramparts in a frozen sea at night, a few lit windows and small figures far out on the ice
Scandinavian history

The surrender of Sveaborg, 1808

Read
Finland seen from high above at night as layered paper lakes and forests divided into soft regions, with small lit towns along the southern coast
Scandinavian history

Finland's province names

Read
A Saami lavvu tent glowing from inside on a snowy fell at night, with reindeer, birch scrub and a frozen lake under the stars
Scandinavian history

Saami genetics and language

Read