Nordic Margins
Finland seen from high above at night as layered paper lakes and forests divided into soft regions, with small lit towns along the southern coast

The genetic mix of people in Finland: blood groups and genomes

Before DNA sequencing, population mixture had to be inferred from blood groups. Nordling built a four-component model of Finland's population from the best data of the 1970s.

Scandinavian history 6 min read

Finland has two large language communities and a third, much smaller one in the north. Most of the population speaks Finnish, a Finnic language closely related to Estonian. Along the western and southern coasts lives the Swedish-speaking minority, the Finland-Swedes. In Lapland live the Saami. If language were a reliable guide to ancestry, Finns would resemble Estonians and Finland-Swedes would resemble Swedes. Blood-group surveys of the twentieth century showed that neither was quite true, and Carl O. Nordling set out to explain why.

The data: Nevanlinna's survey and the ABO era

His raw material was the work of the Finnish geneticist Heikki R. Nevanlinna, whose 1973 study Suomen väestörakenne ("The population structure of Finland") gave allele frequencies for 19 blood-group and serum-protein markers, broken down by county and by language group. Comparable figures existed for Estonia and for regions of Sweden, and the global compilation by Arthur Mourant and colleagues (1976) made it possible to compare Finland with populations elsewhere.

Nordling noticed that genetic differences within Finland followed dialect regions more than administrative borders. He grouped the population into four units: Finland-Swedes, the Finns of the southwest (Turku and Pori), the Finns of the Häme dialect area (which in his grouping included Uusimaa and Vaasa), and the Finns of the east. Differences between counties inside each group looked random to him; differences between the groups looked systematic.

Distances, indices and an unknown component

He first measured genetic distance between groups, using a root-mean-square of the differences in allele frequency. Distances could suggest mixture: if a population sat between two others and its distances to them added up to the distance between them, it might be a blend of the two. On this measure the Häme Finns looked like a fairly good mixture of Finland-Swedes and East Finns. The surprise was that the East Finns, with the least Swedish influence, were the group farthest from the Estonians, whose language is so close to theirs.

To pull the components apart he built simple indices. He used the markers N and P, frequent among Swedes and other Europeans, to define a "European" scale, and the markers B and Cde, frequent among Estonians, to define an "Estonian" one. The East Finns scored low on both. Something else had to account for about a third of their gene pool, and that something had extreme values for A2, the Duffy allele Fya, the serum protein variant Gc1, and very low values for the Rh haplotype cde. In Mourant's tables only one population matched that description: the Saami.

A four-part recipe

Nordling then tried to reproduce the measured frequencies of each Finnish group by mixing hypothetical source populations. Three components, a Scandinavian one, a northeastern Saami one and a component that would combine with the Scandinavian one to yield modern Estonians, gave good fits for the East Finns, Häme Finns and Finland-Swedes. The southwestern Finns did not fit, which he took as a sign of a fourth, unidentified element. He also found that his best Scandinavian component looked less like Swedes in general and more like the people of southern Norrland and northern Dalarna with a modest Saami admixture.

He was candid about the precision. The calibration of his indices was an assumption, not a measurement, and small changes in the frequencies of his invented components would shift the proportions. What he claimed was stable was the pattern: Finns of all regions and Finland-Swedes alike carried Scandinavian, Baltic-Finnic and Saami ancestry in different proportions, with the Saami share highest in the east.

What genome-wide studies show

Since the 2000s, studies using hundreds of thousands of DNA markers have redrawn the genetic map of Finland, and several of Nordling's observations hold up in broad terms.

The most consistent finding is a sharp east–west division within Finland, one of the strongest internal differences found in any European country. Eastern and western Finns differ more from each other than many neighboring national populations do, and the boundary roughly follows old settlement and dialect lines. Finns as a whole also carry a small but clear share of ancestry related to populations of Siberia, the same component found at higher levels in the Saami and in some other Uralic-speaking groups. That fits Nordling's identification of a northern, Saami-like contribution.

Modern studies also stress something his mixing model left out: the effect of small founding populations and isolation. Much of eastern and northern Finland was settled permanently by small groups in the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries, and repeated bottlenecks enriched certain rare variants. The result is the so-called Finnish disease heritage, a set of several dozen inherited conditions that are unusually common in Finland and rare elsewhere. Drift of this kind can make a population look "unusual" on blood-group tables without any extra ancestral component.

As for the Finland-Swedes, genome data place them close to their Finnish-speaking neighbors, with a somewhat larger Scandinavian share than inland Finns. That agrees with the history: the coastal Swedish-speaking population arose from medieval settlers from Sweden who lived alongside and intermarried with Finnic-speaking communities for centuries.

Limits of the 1970s method

Nordling's paper ended with the claim that no alternative theory described the composition of these groups in any other way. That was a strong statement even for its time, and it no longer holds. Blood-group markers are few, several are influenced by selection, and frequencies in small regional samples carry wide error margins. Modern methods model many ancestral sources at once and can separate mixture from drift, which the arithmetic of indices cannot. His four-part recipe should be read as an early, ingenious attempt to see structure in limited data, not as a result.

His instinct that the Saami contribution explains the peculiarity of eastern Finns has proved partly right, and so has his insistence that language and ancestry do not line up neatly. The same reasoning applied to the Saami themselves is the subject of the essay on Saami genetics and language, and the history of the Swedish-speaking coast is followed in the Finland-Swedes series. A related question of names is treated in the essay on Finland's provinces.

Questions and answers

Are Finns genetically different from other Europeans?

Finns are clearly European in ancestry, but they stand out in several ways: a pronounced east–west difference within the country, a small share of ancestry related to Siberian populations, and the effects of past population bottlenecks, which have made some rare inherited conditions unusually common. These features make Finland a frequent subject of population-genetic research.

What data did Nordling use?

He relied mainly on Heikki Nevanlinna's 1973 survey of 19 blood-group and serum-protein markers across Finnish counties and language groups, together with comparable data from Sweden and Estonia and the world tables compiled by Arthur Mourant and colleagues in 1976. From these he built genetic distances, indices and mixing models.

Are Finland-Swedes genetically closer to Swedes or to Finns?

Genome-wide studies find Finland-Swedes genetically close to the Finnish-speaking populations living near them, with a larger Scandinavian component than inland Finns. Their language reflects medieval settlement from Sweden, while their ancestry reflects centuries of mixing with Finnish speakers in the same coastal regions.

Was Nordling right about a Saami component?

Partly. Modern data confirm that Finns, especially in the east and north, carry ancestry shared with the Saami and with Siberian populations. His specific percentages, however, rested on assumed calibrations and a handful of blood-group markers, and later researchers explain much of eastern Finland's distinctiveness by founder effects and drift.

Continue the voyage

A small Viking-age trading town on a lake island at night: turf-roofed longhouses, boats at a wooden jetty and a tiny chapel on the hill
Scandinavian history

Ansgar and the location of Birca

Read
A snow-covered siege trench lit by lanterns below a dark fortress on a cliff, with distant soldiers in long coats and flares in the winter sky
Scandinavian history

The death of Charles XII

Read
A grey stone island fortress with bastions and ramparts in a frozen sea at night, a few lit windows and small figures far out on the ice
Scandinavian history

The surrender of Sveaborg, 1808

Read