Nordling opened his biographical essay with a statement about method. A theory, he wrote, is a tool for organizing facts, and a good one fits the most facts in the simplest way. By that standard he thought the Stratford attribution added little to anyone's understanding of the plays, while the Derby theory had led him to the German Hamlet and to his reading of the delay. Readers will note that usefulness and truth are different tests. The biography below separates what the records show from what Nordling inferred.
A Lancashire childhood and an Oxford college
William Stanley was born around 1561, the younger son of Henry Stanley, 4th Earl of Derby, and Margaret Clifford. Through his mother he descended from Mary Tudor, younger daughter of Henry VII, which gave the family a place in the anxious arithmetic of the Elizabethan succession. The Stanleys were among the greatest landowners in the north of England. Their seats were Lathom House, near Ormskirk, and Knowsley, now on the edge of Liverpool, and they kept town houses in Chester and on Channon Row in Westminster. Lathom was destroyed after the Civil War; the family chapel in Ormskirk parish church, where William was buried, survives.
He studied at St John's College, Oxford, with his brothers in the 1570s. Nordling noted that St John's had a tradition of student theatricals and guessed that William tried his hand at plays there. He also recorded that the boy had been admitted to Gray's Inn as an infant, a common way for noble families to reserve a place.
Nordling assumed that a child of Lathom grew up speaking the Lancashire dialect, which connects with the dialect counts discussed in the essay on the author's person.
A grand tour of uncertain extent
In 1582 Stanley left for several years on the Continent with his tutor, Richard Lloyd. The first part of the journey, in France, is documented. After that the record thins. A popular ballad, Sir William Stanley's Garland, reprinted in Leeds in 1814, sends him to Spain, Italy, Germany, Egypt, Jerusalem, Turkey, Russia and even Greenland. Nordling recognized it as folk romance but noted how far its list overlaps with the countries the plays seem to know. He imagined Stanley on the Bosporus, studying the current he believed lies behind Othello's image of the Pontic Sea, and at Elsinore in 1585, as argued in the essay on Kronborg. Neither visit is documented.
He also speculated that Stanley served in the Low Countries before the Armada of 1588 and found in the night scene before Agincourt in Henry V the voice of someone who had talked with soldiers on the eve of battle. That too is conjecture.
Earl of Derby and lord of the Isle of Man
The family's link with the theater is documented. William's elder brother Ferdinando, Lord Strange, was patron of a company, Lord Strange's Men, which performed at court and at Henslowe's Rose in the early 1590s and included actors who later joined the Lord Chamberlain's Men. Nordling saw in the noble households of the Stanleys the setting the plays depict when a lord receives traveling players, in Hamlet and in the induction to The Taming of the Shrew.
Their father died in 1593 and Ferdinando succeeded as 5th Earl, only to die suddenly in April 1594. William became 6th Earl of Derby and lord of the Isle of Man, which the Stanleys had held since the early fifteenth century. Ferdinando's daughters disputed the inheritance, and the litigation dragged on for years. Nordling linked the lawsuit with Derby's admission to Lincoln's Inn and with the legal vocabulary of the plays.
In January 1595 Derby married Elizabeth de Vere, daughter of the Earl of Oxford and granddaughter of Lord Burghley, at Greenwich, with the queen present. A Midsummer Night's Dream has been connected with that wedding by some scholars, one of several aristocratic marriages proposed as its occasion. Nordling went further and claimed it was written for the day. He also believed that the courtship began years earlier, at the queen's entertainment at Elvetham in 1591. In May 1601 Derby was installed as a Knight of the Garter, and Nordling linked The Merry Wives of Windsor, with its fairy blessing on the Garter stalls at Windsor and the motto "Honi soit qui mal y pense," to that honor. Scholars more often associate the play with the Garter feast of 1597.
Fenner's letters and the plays for James
The decisive document for all Derby supporters is the pair of letters written in June 1599 by the Catholic agent George Fenner, who reported that the Earl was busy penning comedies for the common players. That Derby wrote plays is therefore well attested. That any of them survive under another name is the hypothesis.
Nordling also noted that in 1591 the playwrights Thomas Kyd and Christopher Marlowe were writing in the service of an unnamed lord, as Kyd told the authorities after his arrest in 1593. Some historians have suggested that lord was Ferdinando Stanley. Nordling suggested instead that the lord used the two men's names, as he used Shakespeare's.
His boldest reading concerned the accession of James VI in 1603. Queen Anne was the daughter of Frederick II of Denmark, and in Nordling's account she had acted at Kronborg as a child opposite Stanley. Hamlet, printed in 1603 and 1604, warned a king against murdering a rival claimant, he argued, and Macbeth, the one play set in Scotland, warned James again a few years later. Derby was not harmed. Most critics read Macbeth as flattering James, with its witches and its line of Banquo's royal heirs, which leaves the warning theory isolated.
The Folios and the Droeshout portrait
Derby lived until September 1642, the month Parliament closed the London theaters. He had three sons; the eldest, James, became the 7th Earl and was executed after the Battle of Worcester in 1651. The second, Robert, is commemorated in Chelsea Old Church.
Nordling's last claims concern books. He argued that the First Folio of 1623 was too costly to be a normal commercial venture and that its author must have financed it, and that the careful revisions in the Second Folio of 1632 show the old Earl himself correcting his work. He also compared Martin Droeshout's engraved portrait in the First Folio with a painted portrait of Derby and found the same mouth, nose and brows. Historians of the book trade see the Folio as a calculated investment by a syndicate of stationers led by Edward Blount and William and Isaac Jaggard, and the Second Folio's changes as the work of an editor. The resemblance of the portraits is in the eye of the beholder.
He ended by calling for computer analysis of all English plays from 1580 to 1640 to sort out Derby's share. In the years since, computational studies of early modern drama have grown into a large field, and they have mapped collaboration in the canon in detail. None has assigned any play to Derby. For the shape of the overall argument, see who wrote Hamlet, and why.
Questions and answers
When did William Stanley, 6th Earl of Derby, live?
He was born around 1561 and died on 29 September 1642, aged about 81. He succeeded his brother Ferdinando as Earl in April 1594, married Elizabeth de Vere in 1595, and became a Knight of the Garter in 1601. In later life he handed much of the management of his estates to his son James.
Who were Lord Strange's Men?
They were the acting company patronized by Ferdinando Stanley, Lord Strange, Derby's elder brother. In the early 1590s they played at court and at the Rose theater, performing plays such as The Jew of Malta. After Ferdinando's death in 1594, several of their actors helped form the Lord Chamberlain's Men, the company Shakespeare belonged to.
Was A Midsummer Night's Dream written for a wedding?
Many scholars think it may have been written for an aristocratic marriage, but no record says so. Candidates include the wedding of William Stanley and Elizabeth de Vere at Greenwich in January 1595 and that of Thomas Berkeley and Elizabeth Carey in February 1596. Others think it was written for the public stage from the start.
What is the Droeshout portrait?
It is the engraved portrait of Shakespeare on the title page of the First Folio of 1623, signed by Martin Droeshout. Ben Jonson's verses facing it praise its likeness. Droeshout was young and probably never saw his subject, so he is thought to have worked from an earlier image. Together with the Stratford bust, it is one of only two portraits with a reasonable claim to show Shakespeare.



