Every field has examples of consensus that turned out to be wrong, and Nordling collected them with relish. For three decades textbooks stated that human cells contain 48 chromosomes, until Joe Hin Tjio and Albert Levan counted 46 in Lund in 1956, and the correction was accepted almost at once. In 1897 a young French army doctor, Ernest Duchesne, described in his thesis how a Penicillium mold inhibited bacteria in infected guinea pigs, and the work was forgotten until long after Alexander Fleming's discovery of 1928. From such cases Nordling drew a lesson he applied to literary history: a whole profession can share an error, and sometimes it is an outsider who corrects it.
The examples are real, though they cut both ways. The chromosome count was revised quickly once better evidence came in, which suggests that consensus in science does respond to data. The question for the authorship debate is whether the data are as strong as Nordling believed.
How scholars answered the doubters
He reviewed the defenders of the Stratford attribution one by one. In 1917 Gordon Crosse framed the issue as one of comparative probability: even granting that the Stratford man seems an unlikely author, can any other candidate be shown to be likelier? Nordling thought the reasoning sound and complained that Crosse never revisited it after Lefranc proposed Derby the following year.
The Scottish scholar J. S. Smart, in Shakespeare: Truth and Tradition (1928), devoted much of his book to demolishing the Bacon theory, which he did effectively. His main positive evidence was the First Folio, whose prefaces are signed by the actors John Heminges and Henry Condell. Frank W. Wadsworth's The Poacher from Stratford (1958) surveyed all the anti-Stratfordian theories, gave Derby four pages, and argued in an epilogue that the evidence for Shakespeare is the same kind of evidence historians accept for any other event of the past. H. N. Gibson's The Shakespeare Claimants (1962) examined Bacon, Oxford, Marlowe and Derby.
Nordling's complaints about these books were partly about tone. He felt that Wadsworth ridiculed A. W. Titherley without answering his best arguments, and that Gibson reserved the word "theory" for the rivals while treating the Stratford attribution as fact. These are complaints readers can judge for themselves. Wadsworth's book in particular is still regarded as a fair-minded history of the controversy.
Two prefaces under examination
The center of the essay is the First Folio of 1623. It opens with two prose epistles signed by Heminges and Condell: a dedication to the brothers William and Philip Herbert, Earls of Pembroke and Montgomery, and an address "To the great Variety of Readers." They say the actors gathered their late friend's plays to keep his memory alive, and they claim, famously, that they "scarce received from him a blot in his papers."
Nordling attacked their credibility on two grounds. First, the claim of clean papers sits oddly with the many textual problems in the Folio. Second, the style seemed to him far too learned for two working actors. The dedication runs to long, balanced sentences of about 50 words on average, full of subordinate clauses and classical allusion. The address to readers switches between that manner and a brisk, advertising tone of short sentences. He compared both with the dedications of Venus and Adonis and The Rape of Lucrece, signed by Shakespeare, and found similar sentence lengths and proportions of long words.
He then ran the test from Identifying an author. The prefaces contain 895 words. About ten percent of them are words used fewer than 20 times in Shakespeare, the same rate as in the plays. He listed 15 expressions shared with Shakespeare, of which only four occur in Spenser, and calculated long odds against coincidence. His conclusion was that the author of the plays wrote the prefaces himself and borrowed the actors' names, much as Defoe presented Robinson Crusoe as a castaway's own account, or Montesquieu dressed his Persian Letters as the correspondence of foreign visitors.
The other explanation for the prefaces
Scholars agree with part of this. The literary polish of the Folio epistles has been noticed since the eighteenth century, when the editor George Steevens suggested that Ben Jonson had a hand in them, and many still think so. Jonson was closely involved in the Folio: he wrote the poem facing the Droeshout portrait and the long tribute "To the memory of my beloved, the Author." On that reading, the prefaces were drafted or polished by a professional writer and signed by the two actors who gathered the texts, which was ordinary practice for prefaces.
That explanation accounts for the learned style without requiring the author to be alive in 1623, and it leaves Heminges and Condell where the documents put them. Both were longtime members of Shakespeare's company, both are named in his will, which leaves them money to buy memorial rings, and both had every opportunity to know who wrote the plays they had acted in for two decades. The literary style of a preface says little about the identity of the playwright whose work it introduces.
Nordling's stylistic figures suffer from the same weaknesses as his test of Derby's letters. Fifteen phrases chosen from a text of 895 words and searched for in a canon of almost 900,000 will usually be found there, and the assumption of independent odds is untested.
Belief as an emotional preference
The essay ends on psychology. Wadsworth had written that the authorship question matters to many people on emotional grounds. Nordling agreed and turned the point around. The story of the glover's son who became the greatest poet, he argued, appeals for the same reasons as Cinderella: it promises that genius needs no privilege. He thought that appeal had protected the Stratford attribution from scrutiny.
Defenders of the tradition make the mirror-image charge, that the doubters cannot accept genius without a title. Shapiro's Contested Will (2010) traces exactly this snobbery in the early Baconians and Oxfordians. Each side, in other words, accuses the other of the same weakness. The way out is the one both claim to want: documents. Nordling's own view of why the profession resisted his evidence is developed in The establishment is unyielding, and the life of his candidate in The real Shakespeare.
Questions and answers
Who were John Heminges and Henry Condell?
They were actors and shareholders in the King's Men, Shakespeare's company, for many years. Both are named in his will of 1616, which left each of them money for a memorial ring. In 1623 they signed the dedication and the address to readers in the First Folio, presenting themselves as the friends who collected his plays.
Did Ben Jonson write the First Folio prefaces?
It is a long-standing suggestion. George Steevens proposed it in the eighteenth century because of resemblances to Jonson's own prose, and several modern scholars find it likely that Jonson drafted or revised the epistles. Jonson certainly contributed two poems to the Folio. No document confirms his authorship of the prose prefaces.
What is The Poacher from Stratford?
It is a book by the American scholar Frank W. Wadsworth, published in 1958, that surveys the history of the Shakespeare authorship controversy from the Baconians onward. It treats the Bacon, Oxford, Derby and other theories in turn and defends the traditional attribution. Its title refers to the legend that the young Shakespeare poached deer near Stratford.
When was the correct human chromosome number established?
In 1956, when Joe Hin Tjio and Albert Levan, working in Lund, Sweden, reported 46 chromosomes in human cells using improved techniques. The figure of 48 had been accepted since the 1920s. The new count was confirmed and accepted within a short time, which is often cited as an example of science correcting itself.



