The biography itself is short and undisputed. William Shakespeare was baptized in Stratford-upon-Avon in April 1564, the son of John Shakespeare, a glover and town official. At eighteen he married Anne Hathaway, who was eight years older and already pregnant. By the early 1590s he was in London as an actor, later a sharer in the Lord Chamberlain's Men, and he invested in property both in London and at home. He died in Stratford in 1616, a wealthy man, and was buried in Holy Trinity Church.
Nordling did not question any of this. His question was a lawyer's one: which of these records connects the man to the writing?
Handwriting and the six signatures
The surest proof that someone wrote a text is a manuscript in his hand that matches his private letters. For Shakespeare there is very little to work with. No letter by him survives. What does survive are six signatures, all from the last four years of his life (on legal documents of 1612 and 1613 and on the three sheets of his will), spelled in different ways and, in Nordling's word, "abortive."
There is also a manuscript play, Sir Thomas More, written by several hands and never printed in its time. Three pages of an added scene, in which More calms a riot against foreigners in London, are in a hand paleographers call Hand D. Since the early twentieth century many scholars have attributed Hand D to Shakespeare, on grounds of style and of resemblances to the signatures. Nordling accepted that the passage was by the author of the plays. What he denied was that six late signatures could show it was by the man from Stratford. Comparing a few signatures with a page of rapid drafting written perhaps twenty years earlier is, he argued, too thin a basis.
Specialists reply that the identification of Hand D does not rest on handwriting alone. It also rests on spelling habits, imagery and vocabulary shared with the printed plays, and the attribution has been widely accepted, though not universally.
A common name and a printed spelling
Nordling next took up the name. "William Shakespeare," with variants, was not a rare name in sixteenth-century England. He noted the burial in Stratford in 1590 of one "Thomas Greene, alias Shakspere" as a sign that the surname could also be borrowed.
He then made a distinction he kept throughout the essays. On the printed title pages the name is almost always "Shakespeare," often hyphenated as "Shake-speare." In the Stratford records and in most personal references the spelling varies, frequently as "Shakspere" or "Shaksper." Nordling reserved "Shakespeare" for the author and "Shakspere" for the actor, leaving open whether they were the same person. He pointed out that the name appeared on the title pages of plays no modern editor accepts as Shakespeare's, such as The London Prodigal (1605) and A Yorkshire Tragedy (1608), which shows that publishers used the name freely.
Scholars accept the point about the apocrypha but read it differently. Booksellers put the name on weak plays because it sold, which suggests the name was already well known as that of a working playwright. Spelling in the period was unstable for almost everyone, and the variants do not by themselves suggest two different men.
Payments, letters and Greene's "Shake-scene"
Many dramatists of the time sold scripts to theater owners, and the diary of Philip Henslowe, who ran the Rose, records dozens of such payments. Shakespeare does not appear as a paid author in it. Nordling drew attention to an entry for a play called Troilus and Cressida in 1599, paid to Thomas Dekker and Henry Chettle. Most scholars treat that as a different play on the same popular story, and they explain Shakespeare's absence simply: Henslowe's records concern the Admiral's Men and other companies, while Shakespeare wrote for a rival company whose accounts are lost.
Nordling also listed the personal references to the Stratford man by people who knew him: a cousin, a fellow actor who left him a small bequest, a Stratford neighbor who mentioned him in a letter. None of them, he observed, says anything about writing. The one early allusion to an actor-playwright, Robert Greene's sneer at an "upstart crow" and "Shake-scene" in 1592, he dismissed as hearsay from a man with no known personal acquaintance.
Mainstream historians read Greene's passage as the clearest early evidence that Shakespeare was writing plays in London by 1592, since it parodies a line from Henry VI, Part 3. They also cite Francis Meres in 1598, the title pages, the Revels accounts for court performances, and the testimony of Ben Jonson, who knew Shakespeare personally and wrote about him both in the First Folio and in private notes.
What the will and the settings leave out
Two further absences mattered to Nordling. Shakespeare's will names no books and no manuscripts, though the plays draw on a large library of chronicles, classical authors and Italian tales. And none of the 37 plays is set in a country town like Stratford or behind the scenes of a London theater. If an author's own life usually leaks into his work, Nordling asked, where is this one's?
He added a linguistic point that recurs throughout the series. The regional words in the plays, according to his count, belong far more to the dialect of Lancashire, Cheshire and Yorkshire than to Warwickshire. That argument is developed in the essay on the author's person and the list of dialect words.
The standard replies are well rehearsed. Wills of the period often omit books, which could pass with the household goods to the residuary heir. Playwrights wrote what companies could sell, and London audiences wanted kings, lovers and foreign courts, not Warwickshire farmers. Shakespeare's settings do include English material, from the Boar's Head tavern to Windsor and the Forest of Arden, a name also borne by a forest near Stratford.
The First Folio as a starting point
The essay ends with the First Folio of 1623, the collected edition that fixed the identification of author and actor. Nordling stressed that it appeared seven years after the actor's death and argued that its editors could not have known what he had or had not done in private. In his view the Folio did not prove the identity. It inaugurated it, and later scholarship took it as an axiom.
To press the point he compared the Stratford attribution to geocentric astronomy and to modern cosmology, and he named Abel Lefranc as the scholar whose case for another author had been ignored. Those comparisons show the temper of his writing more than they add evidence. Historians would say the Folio is exactly the kind of testimony they rely on: its editors, Heminges and Condell, were the actor's colleagues of twenty years, mentioned in his will, and they were in a position to know. Nordling's reply to that, which turns on the style of the Folio prefaces, comes in the essay Credence and science.
Questions and answers
How many signatures of William Shakespeare survive?
Six are accepted. They appear on a deposition in a lawsuit of 1612, on two documents concerning the purchase of the Blackfriars Gatehouse in London in 1613, and on the three sheets of his will of 1616. They are spelled in several ways and were written late in his life, which limits their use for comparing handwriting.
What is Hand D in Sir Thomas More?
Hand D is the label given to one of several writers whose handwriting appears in the manuscript of Sir Thomas More, a collaborative play from the 1590s. Hand D wrote a three-page scene in which More quells the "Ill May Day" riot. Many scholars believe the hand is Shakespeare's, and the passage is often printed in modern complete works.
Why does Henslowe's diary not mention Shakespeare?
Philip Henslowe managed the Rose playhouse and financed the Admiral's Men, a rival company. Shakespeare wrote for the Lord Chamberlain's Men, later the King's Men, whose business papers have not survived. Historians therefore do not expect his name among Henslowe's payments. The Troilus and Cressida recorded there in 1599 is generally regarded as a different play.
Who was the "upstart crow"?
The phrase comes from Greene's Groatsworth of Wit (1592), a pamphlet published under the name of the dying playwright Robert Greene. It warns fellow writers against an actor who thinks himself "the only Shake-scene in a country" and parodies a line from Henry VI, Part 3. Most scholars take it as an attack on Shakespeare as a rising playwright.



