Nordic Margins
A writing desk at night with a quill, an inkwell, a closed leather folio and a candle, a lit town beyond the window

Prince Hamlet and Mr. Shakespeare: Is the Prince a Self-Portrait?

Critics have proposed many models for Prince Hamlet, from the Earl of Essex to James VI. Nordling argued that the closest model was the author himself, and listed the traits the prince and the playwright share.

Shakespeare and the authorship question 5 min read

The search for a real person behind Hamlet is almost as old as the search for the author. Robert Devereux, Earl of Essex, Elizabeth's brilliant and unstable favorite, has been suggested. So has James VI of Scotland, whose father was murdered and whose mother married the man widely blamed for it. A Danish candidate is the physician Peder Sørensen, known as Petrus Severinus. Nordling thought each of these produced a few resemblances and no more.

He gave more weight to a remark by J. H. E. Brock, who wrote in a small book of 1935, The Dramatic Purpose of Hamlet, that Shakespeare had left in Hamlet a full-length portrait of his own mind. Brock offered no evidence. Nordling set out to supply some, treating the author's identity as open and asking only which traits the prince and the playwright demonstrably share.

Italian, theater and blank verse

The first trait is a command of Italian. Hamlet says the story of the murder play is "extant, and written in very choice Italian," which assumes he can judge Italian style. The author of The Taming of the Shrew gives Petruchio and Hortensio a short exchange of correct Italian greetings.

The second is a love of the theater. When the players arrive, Hamlet is told they are the tragedians he used to enjoy. He remembers a play that "was never acted, or if it was, not above once," a piece that pleased "not the million," and he recites a long passage from it from memory. He offers to write a speech of "some dozen or sixteen lines" for insertion into the evening's play. He lectures the actors on how to speak and warns the clowns not to improvise.

Nothing in the plot requires any of this, Nordling observed. Saxo's Amleth wrote no verse and directed no actors. No other major character in Shakespeare, apart from the lord in the induction to The Shrew, shows the same interest in plays and acting. Nordling suggested that an author who identified himself with his hero had given him his own hobbies.

He added his linguistic finding. Across the plays, northern dialect words appear at about five per 10,000 words. In Hamlet's own lines, by his count, the rate rises to about 30. A Danish prince has no reason to speak like a man from Lancashire, unless the author wrote his lines in his own unguarded idiom.

Soliloquies and an unpacked heart

Hamlet speaks more than 1,500 lines in Q2, and over 200 of them are soliloquies, more than any other principal character in Shakespeare. Nordling read them as the place where the author exposes himself. In "O, what a rogue and peasant slave am I," Hamlet first marvels that an actor can weep for Hecuba, which Nordling thought was a non-actor's wonder at an actor's craft, and then reproaches himself for unpacking his heart with words, which he thought was a writer's complaint.

The other trait he stressed is irresolution. Hamlet knows his resolution is "sicklied o'er with the pale cast of thought." Nordling claimed the author showed the same weakness in the way the play was revised: hundreds of changes between Q1 and Q2 and more between Q2 and the Folio, some of them returning to Q1's wording. He pointed to the stage direction for the clergyman at Ophelia's grave, "Priest" in Q1, "Doctor" in Q2, "Priest" again in the Folio, and to the courtiers' names, which move from Rossencraft and Gilderstone to Rosencraus and Guyldensterne to Rosincrance and Guildensterne.

Here the evidence is weakest. Variant spellings and stage directions in early printed plays are usually the work of scribes and compositors, who spelled names as they pleased, and scholars do not read them as the author's hesitation.

A prince above the rules

Nordling also noticed the prince's sense of standing above ordinary morality. Hamlet dismisses Polonius's death with a shrug and calls Rosencrantz and Guildenstern "baser nature" caught between mighty opposites. He rebukes his schoolfellows for trying to "pluck out the heart of my mystery" while doing exactly that to the king with his play. He lectures his mother on her remarriage with a severity he never turns on himself.

Nordling connected this with passages in which the author seems to share the attitude. Henry V tells Princess Katharine that kings are "the makers of manners," and Nordling read the line as personal. He also found, in a dialogue in Twelfth Night about Olivia's painted face, a daring joke at the queen's expense, and in the closet scene a reproach that the new king James, whose mother had married her husband's suspected murderer, could hardly miss. Neither reading is common among critics, who point out that the closet scene is already present in shorter form in Q1 and in the source tradition.

Handwriting and fencing

Two smaller details ended the essay. Hamlet recalls that he once held it, as statesmen do, "a baseness to write fair," and tried to forget his good handwriting until it did him "yeoman's service." The passage is not needed for the plot and is missing from Q1. Nordling took it as a writer's aside.

The final duel, with its call of hits and its judge, is written with technical precision. Many playwrights would have marked "they fight" and moved on. Shakespeare scripted the bout, which Nordling took as evidence that the author fenced.

He concluded that Brock had been right: Hamlet is, in part, the author. That much many critics would grant in a general sense, since writers lend their characters something of themselves. Nordling meant more. If Hamlet is the author, and the prince resembles the Earl of Derby in his reluctance to claim a throne, then the author is Derby. That further step is examined in Identifying an author and rests on the case outlined in Why does Hamlet tarry?. It is accepted only by the small circle of Derby's supporters.

Questions and answers

Who has been proposed as the model for Prince Hamlet?

Suggestions include the Earl of Essex, James VI of Scotland, the Danish physician Peder Sørensen, and Shakespeare's son Hamnet, who died in 1596 aged eleven. Nordling proposed William Stanley, Earl of Derby. None of these identifications is generally accepted, and many critics doubt that Hamlet was modeled on any one person.

Why does Hamlet know so much about acting?

Within the play, he is a prince who has long enjoyed the company of players and knows their repertory. Critics often read his advice to the players as reflecting Shakespeare's own views as a working actor and dramatist. Nordling read the same passages differently, as the words of an aristocratic amateur who wrote and rehearsed plays without acting professionally.

How long is the role of Hamlet?

Hamlet is the longest role in Shakespeare, at roughly 1,500 lines in the fuller texts, more than a third of the play. The complete play, combining Q2 and the Folio, runs to about four hours on stage, and most productions cut it. Nordling took the length itself as a sign of the author's personal investment.

Is the fencing match in Hamlet realistic?

It is detailed. Hamlet and Laertes fight with foils for a wager, Osric acts as judge and calls the hits, and the king offers odds on the result. The scene reflects the fashion for rapier fencing among the Elizabethan gentry and the fencing displays common on the London stage. Whether it proves the author fenced is another matter.

Continue the voyage

An early seventeenth-century printing workshop at night with a wooden hand press, type cases and an oil lamp
Shakespeare and the authorship question

Credence and science

Read
A large Tudor manor house of brick and timber with lit windows, reflected in a moat among old trees under a crescent moon
Shakespeare and the authorship question

The real Shakespeare?

Read
London around 1600 across the Thames at night: houses on the old bridge with lit windows, church spires and small boats with lanterns
Shakespeare and the authorship question

The Establishment is unyielding

Read