Nordic Margins
The empty galleried interior of an Elizabethan wooden playhouse at night, a bare stage with two pillars and lanterns along the tiers

Why Does Hamlet Tarry? A Prince Who Delays Because He Fears the Crown

Critics have offered dozens of reasons for Hamlet's delay. Nordling's is political and psychological at once: the prince will not kill Claudius while doing so would put the Danish crown on his own head.

Shakespeare and the authorship question 6 min read

In Saxo's version of the story, Amleth waits years before taking revenge, and the reasons are plain. He is a boy when his father is killed, and his uncle Feng keeps guards around him. Belleforest's French retelling of 1570 keeps the same logic. Shakespeare removes both obstacles. Hamlet is a grown man, a student at Wittenberg, and in the third act he finds Claudius alone and kneeling at prayer. He draws his sword and puts it away again. He finally kills the king in the last minutes of the play, almost by accident, and dies himself moments later.

Why he waits so long is the most debated question about the most discussed play in the English language.

A century of answers

Nordling surveyed the main explanations before giving his own. A. C. Bradley, in Shakespearean Tragedy (1904), saw a melancholy so deep that it paralyzed the will. Ernest Jones, the psychoanalyst, argued in Hamlet and Oedipus (1949) that Hamlet cannot punish a man who has done what he himself secretly wished to do. T. S. Eliot, in his essay "Hamlet and His Problems" (1919), judged the play an artistic failure, its hero's emotions exceeding anything the plot supplies. The American scholar E. E. Stoll held that the delay was a convention inherited from older revenge drama. Morris Weitz, in a study of Hamlet criticism published in 1964, catalogued many more.

Nordling was impatient with critics who concluded that the delay could not be explained. He singled out Arthur Sewell, who wrote in 1951 that Hamlet "defies explanation" as long as the explanation is sought in the prince's character. To Nordling that was an admission of defeat dressed up as a finding. He credited one predecessor with the decisive step: Salvador de Madariaga, who in On Hamlet (1948) portrayed the prince as profoundly self-centered. Egocentricity explained much, Nordling thought, but not everything.

Quick to kill, slow to kill the king

He began from an observation many readers make. Hamlet is not squeamish. He stabs Polonius through the arras without looking. He sends Rosencrantz and Guildenstern to their execution in England with a forged letter and later says they are "not near" his conscience. Both victims had done little more than try to find out his secret. Yet the man who murdered his father, took his throne and married his mother survives every opportunity.

Nordling also rejected the reading that Hamlet thought Claudius was behind the arras. Minutes after Polonius dies, the Ghost reappears and says it has come to "whet thy almost blunted purpose." A ghost that knows everything would not say that to a son who had just tried to kill the king. "I took thee for thy better," Hamlet's words over the body, Nordling took to mean only that he had punished the servant in place of the master.

The throne Hamlet will not take

His explanation started from the constitution of Denmark as the play presents it. Claudius was elected king by the estates. Claudius himself calls Hamlet "the most immediate to our throne," and he admits that the people love the prince. If Hamlet kills Claudius, the election that follows has an obvious result. In Saxo, Amleth kills his uncle and becomes king. The logic of revenge in the play carries the same consequence.

Hamlet never speaks of it. He talks about everything else, death, women, actors, skulls and the nature of man, but not about ruling. Only once, near the end, does he complain that Claudius "popped in between the election and my hopes." Around him every other young man wants the crown. Claudius murdered for it. Laertes returns from France at the head of a mob crying that he should be king. Fortinbras marches in at the end to claim his "rights of memory." Hamlet alone avoids the subject.

Nordling's thesis was that Hamlet postpones the killing as long as it would bring the crown with it. He has been raised to rule, believes as his age did that royal virtue is inherited, and knows in his heart that he is unfit for it. His first reaction to the Ghost's command is the lament that he was "born to set it right." He compares himself unfavorably to Hercules and calls Denmark a prison. His excuses at the prayer scene are, in modern terms, rationalization: reasons produced afterward to justify an avoidance whose real cause he does not understand.

The test comes in the final scene. Laertes tells him the blade was poisoned and that he has less than half an hour to live. Now there is no crown in prospect, and Hamlet kills Claudius at once. Nordling thought the timing settled the matter.

A living model in England

The second half of the essay moves from the play to history. Nordling saw portraits of real people in the court of Elsinore: Frederick II of Denmark, known for his drinking, behind Claudius's carousing, and Lord Burghley behind Polonius, whose advice to his departing son resembles Burghley's own precepts for his son.

For Hamlet he proposed William Stanley, 6th Earl of Derby. In the 1590s Elizabeth I was old and childless, and the succession was the great unspoken question of English politics. Derby's mother, Margaret Clifford, descended from Henry VII's younger daughter Mary, and some observers counted the Stanleys among possible claimants. In June 1599 a Catholic agent named George Fenner, reporting on Derby's intentions, wrote that the Earl was "busy only in penning comedies for the common players." Nordling read this as the portrait of a man who preferred the theater to the throne, exactly like the prince who would rather direct actors than rule.

The parallel continues at the end. Dying, Hamlet gives his voice to Fortinbras. In 1603 Elizabeth was succeeded by James VI of Scotland, a foreign king and Derby's distant cousin, and Derby did nothing to oppose it.

Nordling himself said the play can be understood without any of this. A reader can accept his account of the delay and leave the historical model aside. Literary historians generally do: the reading of the delay is one interpretation among many, and the identification of Hamlet with Derby belongs to the minority case for Derby's authorship, which few accept. His further analysis of how the play grew is in Hamlet in three stages, and the idea of Hamlet as the author's self-portrait in Prince Hamlet and Mr. Shakespeare.

Questions and answers

What are the main explanations for Hamlet's delay?

Classic answers include melancholy (A. C. Bradley), an Oedipal conflict (Ernest Jones), moral scruple about revenge, doubt about the Ghost's honesty, and the claim that the delay is a dramatic convention or an unresolved flaw (E. E. Stoll, T. S. Eliot). Modern critics often combine several. Nordling added the idea that Hamlet avoids the throne that revenge would bring.

Why does Hamlet not kill Claudius at prayer?

Hamlet says that killing a man at prayer would send his soul to heaven, and that he will wait until he can catch Claudius in some sinful act. Nordling regarded this reason as a pretext. Ironically, Claudius admits after Hamlet leaves that his prayer has failed, so the stated reason rests on a mistake the audience can see.

Does Hamlet expect to become king?

The play suggests he could have. Claudius names him as next to the throne, the people favor him, and Hamlet himself says Claudius stepped between "the election and my hopes." Denmark in the play elects its kings, as historical Denmark did, so the crown was not automatic, but Hamlet is plainly the leading candidate.

Who was George Fenner?

George Fenner was an English Catholic agent whose letters of June 1599, discovered by the archivist James Greenstreet and published in 1891, reported that the Earl of Derby was occupied in writing comedies for the public players. The letters are the main documentary basis for the Derby authorship theory. Most scholars accept that Derby wrote plays but note that none survives under his name.

Continue the voyage

A writing desk at night with a quill, an inkwell, a closed leather folio and a candle, a lit town beyond the window
Shakespeare and the authorship question

Prince Hamlet and Mr. Shakespeare

Read
A large Tudor manor house of brick and timber with lit windows, reflected in a moat among old trees under a crescent moon
Shakespeare and the authorship question

Identifying an author

Read
An early seventeenth-century printing workshop at night with a wooden hand press, type cases and an oil lamp
Shakespeare and the authorship question

Credence and science

Read