Viol players know Tobias Hume as one of the most original English composers of his generation. Historians of the Stuart period know him for a strange petition to Parliament in 1642. Nordling, at the end of his Shakespeare essays, connected the two with a third claim of his own: that the prefaces published under Hume's name sound like Shakespeare.
Two books of music for the viol
Almost everything known about Hume's music comes from two printed books. The First Part of Ayres, published in London in 1605 and often called by its running title Musicall Humors, is a large collection of pieces for the lyra viol, the bass viol played chordally from tablature, much as a lute is. Captaine Humes Poeticall Musicke followed in 1607, with pieces for viols in various combinations, songs and descriptive pieces. Together they make up the largest body of lyra viol music by any one composer up to that time.
The music is vivid and sometimes eccentric. There are dances, character pieces with titles such as "A Souldiers Resolution," and songs including the cheerful "Tobacco is like love." In one piece the player is told to drum on the strings with the back of the bow, an early example of the effect later called col legno. Modern players value the books for their technical inventiveness and their exploration of the sonority of the bass viol. Recordings by Jordi Savall and others brought Hume to a wider audience in the late twentieth century.
A soldier's prefaces
Hume introduced himself in print as a soldier first. In a preface addressed to the reader he declared that he did not study eloquence or profess music, that arms had been his profession and music the only effeminate part of him, and that his pieces were his own inventions, not borrowed from Italian songs. He claimed that the bass viol, played his way, could yield music as rich as any instrument, a direct challenge to the lute, the most prestigious instrument of the age. The lutenist John Dowland appears to have taken it personally: the preface to his A Pilgrimes Solace (1612) complains of a gentleman who had stood up for the viol against the lute.
The 1607 book is dedicated to Queen Anne, wife of James I and sister of Christian IV of Denmark. Its dedication is a single long, elaborate sentence followed by a short courtesy, and the queen's own copy carries a handwritten note asking that she hear the music performed by the author on excellent instruments.
Hume's career as a soldier is less well documented than his music. He is said to have served as a mercenary officer in the Swedish army and later in Russia. He was admitted as a poor brother to the Charterhouse in London, the almshouse founded in 1611 by Thomas Sutton, and he died there in April 1645.
The petition of Colonel Hume
In 1642, with Ireland in rebellion and England sliding toward civil war, a pamphlet appeared titled The True Petition of Colonel Hume, addressed to the House of Lords. Its author, describing himself as one of the poor brethren of the Charterhouse, offered to crush the Irish rebels within three months with a hundred or so "instruments of war" of his own design, or lose his head, and to bring in a vast sum of money by sea if given a fleet. He described his poverty in painful detail, including gathering snails among the nettles to eat, and threatened to leave the country to serve another king.
Most historians read the pamphlet as Hume's own, the work of an old soldier fallen on hard times and perhaps no longer in full command of himself. Nordling read it as a hoax. An untitled captain, he argued, would not become a colonel; a colonel would not end in an almshouse; a pensioner could not afford a printer; and no printer would gamble on such a text. From this he concluded that someone wealthy and well placed had used Hume's name to mock the lords, and that the same person might have written the prefaces of the music books.
The argument has weak links. Military titles in foreign service were fluid, and many officers ended their lives poor. Printing a short pamphlet was cheap, and London's presses in 1642 poured out thousands of them, many far stranger than this one.
Phrases shared with Shakespeare
Nordling's evidence for a hidden author was a table of expressions from the Hume texts with near-parallels in Shakespeare. A few examples: "noble spirits" (in Henry VIII), "your sacred person" (also in Henry VIII), "too harsh a style" against Hume's "harsh style" (Richard III), "instruments of war" (Henry IV, Part 1), "brown bread" and "small beer," "humbly beseech," "humbly take my leave." He added a list of rarer words, noting that some of Hume's, such as patronize, gracefully and uncommon, never occur in Shakespeare, while others, such as superfluous, servile and eloquence, do. He also measured the sentence lengths of the prefaces, which average about 30 words in the address to the reader.
He did not name the hidden author in this essay, but the context makes his suggestion plain: a nobleman with a Danish connection to Queen Anne, a love of music and a taste for pen names, who was alive in 1642. That is the profile he had drawn of William Stanley, 6th Earl of Derby, in The real Shakespeare.
The parallels are the weakest evidence in the series. Most of the shared phrases were common formulas of courtly and military English, the kind found in hundreds of dedications and petitions of the period. A writer addressing a queen would naturally write of her "sacred person" and ask to "humbly beseech" her. As with the comparison of Derby's letters, the phrases were chosen because they matched, and no control group of other dedications was tested. Hume's documented life, his service abroad, his Charterhouse place and his distinctive musical voice, gives no reason to doubt that he wrote his own prefaces.
What survives clearly is the music. Hume's books remain in the repertory of viol players, and the soldier who claimed music was the only soft part of him left one of its most personal bodies of work. Readers can follow Nordling's wider argument from the collection overview.
Questions and answers
Who was Tobias Hume?
Tobias Hume (c. 1569–1645) was an English or Scottish soldier and composer who served as a mercenary officer abroad and published two books of music, in 1605 and 1607, mainly for the viol. He spent his last years as a pensioner of the Charterhouse in London, where he died in April 1645. His music is still played and recorded.
What is a lyra viol?
The lyra viol is a small bass viol, or a way of playing the bass viol, used in England in the late sixteenth and seventeenth centuries. It plays chords and melody together, read from tablature like lute music, often in special tunings. Hume's 1605 collection is one of the earliest and largest printed sources for the instrument.
What was The True Petition of Colonel Hume?
It is a pamphlet of 1642 in which Hume, then a pensioner at the Charterhouse, offered the House of Lords his services against the Irish rebellion, promising victory within three months with weapons of his own design. It describes his poverty vividly. Historians generally regard it as genuine; Nordling considered it a hoax by another writer.
Did Tobias Hume and John Dowland quarrel?
Not in person, as far as is known. A preface by Hume claimed the bass viol could equal the lute, the instrument Dowland was famous for. In the address to the reader in his A Pilgrimes Solace (1612), Dowland complained of a gentleman who had argued that the viol was as good as the lute, which is usually read as a reply to Hume.



